Surviving in The Gig Economy:
Don’t Be An Ant

by Christopher Meyer on 12/04/2015

ant.“There’s something happening here,
What it is ain’t exactly clear”

For What It’s Worth, Buffalo Springfield, 1967

Ravinder drives for Uber two nights a week in Los Angeles.  On a farm in rural Poland, Peter tests computer code to complete a programming job he bid for on Odesk.  Across the valley, Peter’s girlfriend wraps penguin Christmas tree ornaments she’s selling on handicraft marketplace, Etsy.

Each is a participant in the new Gig Economy where Internet companies parse work and provide marketplaces for workers and their products and services.

Most of what one reads about the Gig Economy highlights the conflicts between it and existing convention.  Taxi drivers across the globe push back against Uber for taking their customers without having to follow the same rules.  Lawsuits ask courts to decide whether Gig Economy workers are truly contractors or employees.

These are valid concerns that reflect the expanding impact technology has on the world of work.  This piece explores how far can we expect the Gig Economy to expand and what are the consequences?

Relentless Digitization

Gig Economy companies make it easier for rank amateurs to work as part-time contractors by digitizing business processes. A traditional freelancer runs a small but complete business including getting customers, servicing them as well as handling marketing, billing, financing, etc.  Uber, for example, digitizes the taxi business into pieces and does all the marketing, customer acquisition, billing, car routing and satisfaction.  The part-timer just provides their car, gas and drives.

Customers see a single Uber app on their phone.  The behind-the-scenes dissection and aggregation is as invisible as a digital picture that’s been manipulated with Photoshop.

Gig or Gouge?

Odesk provides a marketplace for contractors to bid on small programming or analytic jobs.  I’ve used Odesk to hire people to analyze customer survey data.  I framed the project, provided the raw data on Excel and paid the contractor to analyze and prepare presentation materials. I selected the contractor based on their past experience and certifications and paid far less than it would cost for a traditional research assistant or grad student.

It was a great deal for me but it puts enormous pressure on contractor fees.  People from India compete with folks such as Peter in Poland as well as a student in Sunnyvale, California.  In a developing country, serial Odesk gigs provide a living full time wage.  In a developed country, the same gig is likely below minimum wage.

Odesk demonstrates the global reach of technology.  The days when technology was the province of advanced economies are long gone.  Expertise flows fast and freely in the digital world.  Therefore, so does competition; increasingly in knowledge work.

Contractor vs. Employee

The Fair Labor Standards Act created the distinction between contractor and employee as part of New Deal legislation in 1938.  The primary distinction is work direction and control.  Contractors are assumed to work independently whereas employees are under the control of their boss and company.

This bifurcation made sense seventy years ago when manufacturing was the dominant growth factor in our economy.  I’d argue it’s time to consider another category that slots between the two.  The two category approach wasn’t designed for today’s technology or global economy.

Technology is also encroaching on what we’ve historically considered managerial control.  Doesn’t the software that Uber gives drivers control what they do even if there isn’t a direct Uber boss they report to?  Taking this to a level higher, performance appraisal, a traditional employer-employee process, is usurped by customer satisfaction surveys.  Here’s how that works in practice.

Every Uber trip is rated by customers.  If a driver’s average customer rating drops below a certain point, Uber will no longer contract work to them.  Uber drivers are careful to avoid late night party’ers who might be drunk enough to give anyone a bad review.  The rating process could just as well be called computer mediated supervision.

How Far Can Technology Reach?

Technology initially hit blue collar workers hard.  Lower labor costs sucked manufacturing jobs off shore.  More recently, white collar workers suffered.  For example, analyst work at law firms and tax preparation at accountancies is done offshore.

Those in favor of technology argue that new technology creates more jobs than it destroys.  It’s more accurate to say technology redistributes jobs while possibly creating more.  The job creation side of the equation is a belief versus a proven fact.  Could we be at a tipping point where the time delay between job destruction and new job creation has extended sufficiently such that those displaced really don’t have a chance to retool?

Despite all the retraining efforts, the time retraining takes relative to steady technology evolution makes staying stay on the productive edge a lifetime effort.  Employers with advanced factories such as John Deere struggle to find workers to fill manufacturing jobs that have a higher technology content.

Here’s the kicker.  The impact on white collar jobs is just starting.  As technology capability grows, jobs that depend on tacit knowledge or winemaking skills become vulnerable. For example, technology can now read xrays and MRI’s with high accuracy.  Tumor identification by machine is almost ready for the clinic.

Commonly referred to as machine learning, computers are getting better at nuance.  They don’t just make predetermined corrections based on feedback; they relentlessly experiment and improve.  Don’t expect advances such as IBM’s Watson to be satisfied just playing Jeopardy better than we can.

As the Dave Mathews Band sang, “And all the ants are marching”

Putting the Gig Economy in Perspective

The fact is the current Gig Economy is more smoke than fire.

  • McKinsey & Co. measured contingent work transacted on a digital market place in the U.S. at less than 1% of workers, including some that already had a job.
  • Employment by the Fortune 500 remains consistent at 16-17% of the U.S. workforce for twenty years.
  • Americans who are self-employed and unincorporated has dropped over the decade to about 6.5% of workers today according to the Wall Street Journal. People who hold multiple jobs is 4.8% compared to 5.5% in 2005.

Some suggest that traditional indicators (i.e. GDP and employment) don’t reflect the digital world accurately. Economic Modeling Specialists Intl., a labor market analytics firm, says part-time work grew to 32 million from just over 20 million between 2001 and 2014, rising to almost 18 percent of all jobs.

My take is two-fold.  First, it’s not the size of today’s Gig Economy but the growth rate that matters.  And the current obstacles are normal battles between current players and disruptive newbies.

Second, the Gig Economy is just the latest manifestation of technology’s encroachment on our lives.  Middle aged and older get used to each individual increment such that we potentially lose sight and control over where we’re headed in the long term.  Younger people automatically start with a higher baseline and don’t see a problem.

Will There Be Companies or Just Gigs in the Future?

Ronald Coase won the Nobel prize for defining why companies form.  Coase said that when the transaction costs of managing independent suppliers grows to a certain point, it is more efficient and effective to bring those resources in house.

What the Gig Economy demonstrates is that point is moving further out.  Communication and computers enable Gig Economy companies to coordinate and control work “bits” without owning them.

Creative work is indeed further from digitization than procedural tasks but the marching ants will eventually get there.

And all the little ants are marching
Red and black antennas waving
They all do it the same
They all do it the same way

How do you win in the Gig Economy?  Don’t be an ant.

A Band of Angels Innovation:
The Special Interest Group

October 15, 2015

Angel investing starts with an initial contact, followed by screening that leads to a pitch and perhaps a deal.  There’s an underlying tension in the process.  Entrepreneurs want the angels’ money and to get back to growing their business as quickly as possible. Angels want the entrepreneur’s time to understand the business and investment potential.
Most angel [...]

Read the full article →

Before You Pitch Me, Ask Yourself:
Is Your Company a Me-Too or a Fast Follower?

September 2, 2015

Last week, I listened to seven startups pitches at the Band of Angels Deal Selection committee wondering at least three times, hadn’t I heard this deal before?
Do customers crave another user friendly wearable that counts steps, heartbeats and measures sleep quality better than Apple Watch, FitBit, and Garmin? Is now the right time, to replace [...]

Read the full article →

Clone ‘Em: Bring Instant Leadership to Your Company

August 6, 2015

Clone ‘Em Leads Apple App Store Rankings
Cupertino, CA (AP) August 6, 2015
Latest App Store rankings released this morning reveal that Clone ‘Em, the Leadership Cloning App has risen to first place in the popular Fast Growth category.  Leveraging data from mobile and wearables, Clone ‘Em uses advanced algorithms to prompt new leaders when they’re [...]

Read the full article →

Fearlessness

June 29, 2015

President Obama discussed with comedian Mark Maron how the ups and downs of six years in office had made him a better president (paraphrased below).
As you get older, you might slow down or not jump as high as you used to.  But I know what I’m doing and I’m fearless.  This is not pretending to [...]

Read the full article →

Decimal Point Thinking:
Good for Operators; Dangerous for Innovation

June 19, 2015

Winter in Detroit is rarely pretty.  Pristine snowfalls quickly turn to grey slush that outwits the best pedestrian avoidance maneuvers.  Once that happens, your feet are cold and clammy for the next three hours.
It was on such a day that a new product team was presenting their “comeback” car design to a panel of senior [...]

Read the full article →

The Day After: Apple’s PayPal 2.0

September 10, 2014

I wrote yesterday’s piece before Apple’s product announcement.  While crafting a response to an email comment I received this morning, it struck me that a post-introduction piece might be in order.
In short, the iPhone 6/6 Plus will cover profits, the Watch will spur innovation and Apple Pay is the potential game changer.
Apple’s Passion for Profits
[...]

Read the full article →

Apple New Product Introduction:
Welcome to the Planet of the Ape

September 9, 2014

In a couple of hours, Apple executives will take to the stage.  And millions will be watching because part of our love for Apple is being co-conspirators in the OMG introduction process. While reverence for Steve Jobs will keep “incredibly insane” product descriptions off the table, expect to hear the word “amazing” more than once.
However, [...]

Read the full article →

Zen Start-up Lessons:
What Nest Labs Can Teach Entrepreneurs

February 14, 2014

Nest Labs makes a smarter, Internet- connected thermostat that sells for two to three times conventional models.  Most recently, they’ve introduced a similarly empowered and priced smoke detector.  You might ask if you need a smarter thermostat or smoke detector?  You’ll have a chance to answer that for yourselves in a moment.
Nest was founded by [...]

Read the full article →

The Minimum Viable Business School:
Zipcar Education for Entrepreneurs

February 7, 2014

The hotbed of education experimentation in Silicon Valley are the startup academies, accelerators and hacker boot camps.  Grounded in the minimum viable product philosophy that entrepreneurs harness to speed products to market, these new education entities offer a minimum viable education for tech entrepreneurs.
You know it’s hot because the regulators have come out of the [...]

Read the full article →

Apple New Product Strategy: “Siri…What Did I Miss?”

October 23, 2013

With yesterday’s product announcements Apple confirmed that writing about Apple these days is pretty boring.  No question engineers and designers worked hard to squeeze the iPad line thinner and lighter but, yawn, they’re iPads…now with some free software.  Who hoo.
For those who haven’t moved on to another site, Apple’s actions suggest:

Demand is strong enough to [...]

Read the full article →